VAT exemption for cost sharing groups limited; the ECJ makes a U-turn

On September 21th 2017, the European Court of Justice of the EU (ECJ) has judged in three cases on the VAT exemption for cost sharing groups (article 11-1-u Dutch VAT Act 1968, and 132-1-f EU VAT Directive).In short, the exemption applies to services by cost sharing groups for their members, if these services are directly necessary for the VAT exempt activities of these members or activities for which these members are not subject to tax. Furthermore, the group may only be reimbursed by the members for their share in the mutual costs. In the Dutch regulations, some more conditions need to be met, but the exemption is applied frequently between cooperating parties in day to day practice. The ECJ’s rulings of September 21th 2017 however, have drastically limited the possibilities to apply the exemption.


In the rulings DNB Banka (C-326/15) and Aviva (C-605/15), the ECJ has explained that the exemption can only be used by independent groups of members whose activities are exempt based on article 132 of the VAT Directive (activities in the public interest). Thus, the exemption only applies where the provision of those services by the cost sharing group, contributes directly to the exercise of activities in the public interest referred to in Article 132 of that Directive. This explanation limits the applicability of the exemption in a rigorous way. The current (Dutch and other EU member states’) practice of applying the exemption to cost sharing groups in for instance the banking and insurance sector is not possible anymore. Article 132 exempts for instance medical, educational and syndical activities, but not the more “commercial” services.


The decisions of the ECJ seem to contradict its past rulings on this exemption. The court tries to talk its way out of this contradiction by stating that in earlier rulings, it did not have to rule on the applicability of the exemption on financial or insurance activities as such. It refers explicitly to its ruling of November 20th 2003, Taksatorringen (number C-8/01). However, in this case, the members of the cost sharing group were all insurance companies and the activities that were performed by the group were damage taxation! In both of the rulings now published, the ECJ states that it is the court’s task to “provide the referring court with all those elements for the interpretation of EU law which may be of assistance in adjudicating on the case pending before it, whether or not the referring court has specifically referred to them in its question”. Therefore the remark of the court that it has not looked into the applicability of the exemption to insurance companies in the Taksatorringen case seems rather strange and not convincing. However, this is what the court ruled, so in practice we have to deal with it. The ECJ does make a remark that it has knowledge of the fact that the Taksatorringen case has led to “misunderstandings” in the EU member states, in the sense that in practice, the exemption has been applied in situations where the members of the group were in fact insurance or banking companies. The ECJ reminds the member states that they cannot change their practice retrospectively, as that would mean a breach of the principle of legal certainty. We do not know yet how the Dutch tax authorities (or the tax authorities in other member states) will react to the rulings, but we assume that they will grant a period of grace during which the exemption will remain in place, and parties can adopt the VAT charges or change their structure of cooperation.


Finally, in its third ruling on this subject of the day (commission – Germany; C-616/15), the ECJ explains that a further limitation of the exemption is not at hand. Germany had claimed that the exemption for cost sharing groups should be limited to groups in the medical sector only. Their plea was that – as the exemption is based on article 132-1-f of the VAT Directive, it only applies on the activities of members which are mentioned in article 132-1 letters a to e. However, the ECJ sees no reasons for such a strict restriction.

Do you have questions about this issue? Please contact our tax advisors.